If you need Would You Rather Questions for a Christmas Eve Family Party, the best version is simple, cheerful, and easy for all ages to join. The questions below are made for mixed family groups, from kids to grandparents, and they work well for a cozy evening at home, after dinner, or while waiting for presents, dessert, or a movie.
To keep the game fun, choose questions that are silly, festive, and low-pressure. Christmas Eve is a time for laughter, not awkward debate, so these prompts stay light, family-friendly, and quick to answer.
How to play at a Christmas Eve family party
Read one question at a time and ask everyone to choose between the two options. Players can answer out loud, raise hands, or move to different sides of the room for each choice if you want a more active game.
For a relaxed family gathering, there is no need for scoring. If you want a little competition, give one point for each answer that matches the group majority, or let each player explain their choice for a bonus laugh.
Classic Christmas Eve would you rather questions
- Would you rather open one present tonight and save the rest for tomorrow, or wait and open everything on Christmas morning?
- Would you rather decorate the tree with only red ornaments or only gold ornaments?
- Would you rather eat Christmas cookies for dessert or hot chocolate with marshmallows?
- Would you rather sing every Christmas carol you know or dance to every song on the holiday playlist?
- Would you rather have a snowy Christmas Eve or a cozy rainy Christmas Eve?
- Would you rather wear matching family pajamas or matching ugly Christmas sweaters?
- Would you rather have a giant stack of gifts or one very thoughtful gift?
- Would you rather help wrap presents or help hang lights?
- Would you rather be in charge of the tree topper or the ornaments?
- Would you rather have Christmas dinner early or Christmas breakfast late at night?
- Would you rather listen to holiday music all night or watch a Christmas movie all night?
- Would you rather have a fireplace that crackles all evening or twinkle lights in every room?
- Would you rather make your own gingerbread house or decorate sugar cookies?
- Would you rather receive a gift you really wanted or a surprise gift you never expected?
- Would you rather spend Christmas Eve in your coziest blanket or your warmest slippers?
Silly and laugh-out-loud choices
- Would you rather have tinsel in your hair for a week or glitter on your face for a week?
- Would you rather accidentally wrap a gift in upside-down paper or tape the box shut too well?
- Would you rather talk like Santa all night or laugh like a reindeer all night?
- Would you rather have a cookie that tastes like peppermint toothpaste or cocoa with too much cinnamon?
- Would you rather wear reindeer antlers to dinner or a Santa hat to bed?
- Would you rather be stuck in a snow globe or in a giant gift box?
- Would you rather have bells jingling every time you walk or candy canes in your pockets all day?
- Would you rather build a snowman that keeps tipping over or a gingerbread house with one missing wall?
- Would you rather have elves do your chores for a day or reindeer deliver your snacks for a day?
- Would you rather have a Christmas tree that sings or a wreath that tells jokes?
Questions kids usually love
- Would you rather get a toy that lights up or a toy that makes sounds?
- Would you rather have a pet reindeer or a pet penguin?
- Would you rather make snow angels or build a snow fort?
- Would you rather eat only candy canes or only chocolate coins for one day?
- Would you rather have Santa leave you one huge gift or three smaller gifts?
- Would you rather decorate cookies with sprinkles or frosting?
- Would you rather wear a Christmas crown or a Santa cape?
- Would you rather make a snowman’s nose out of a carrot or a candy cane?
- Would you rather ride in Santa’s sleigh or help guide the reindeer?
- Would you rather have a tree full of lights or a tree full of ornaments?
Questions that work well for teens and adults too
- Would you rather be the first person awake on Christmas morning or the last person to go to bed on Christmas Eve?
- Would you rather be in charge of music or dessert for the whole party?
- Would you rather give every gift by hand or receive every gift by surprise?
- Would you rather spend Christmas Eve baking all night or watching movies all night?
- Would you rather have a perfectly wrapped gift that is boring or a badly wrapped gift that is amazing?
- Would you rather have a quiet Christmas Eve with just family or a big, lively Christmas Eve with lots of guests?
- Would you rather travel to see family on Christmas or have everyone come to you?
- Would you rather be the one who plans the meal or the one who cleans up afterward?
- Would you rather have a holiday playlist on repeat or one classic Christmas movie on repeat?
- Would you rather spend Christmas Eve making memories or making the perfect holiday photo?
Cozy family questions for conversation
- Would you rather share your favorite Christmas memory or your favorite holiday food?
- Would you rather tell a family story or hear one from someone older?
- Would you rather make a new family tradition or keep an old one going forever?
- Would you rather give a handmade gift or receive one?
- Would you rather spend the evening by the tree or by the fireplace?
- Would you rather have a family game night or a family movie night on Christmas Eve?
- Would you rather make everyone laugh with a holiday joke or impress everyone with a holiday song?
- Would you rather have a house that smells like cookies or pine?
- Would you rather unwrap gifts slowly or all at once?
- Would you rather end Christmas Eve with dessert or with a warm drink?
Quick tips for making the game more fun
- Mix easy questions with a few silly ones so younger kids stay engaged.
- Keep the pace moving; short questions work best for a family party.
- Invite players to explain their answers if the group enjoys conversation.
- Use physical movement by having people stand on one side of the room for each choice.
- Avoid overly personal, competitive, or embarrassing questions so everyone feels comfortable joining in.
If you want the game to last longer, print the questions or save them on your phone and let each person take turns reading one aloud. A simple final round works well too: ask everyone to choose between “hot cocoa by the fire” or “opening one mystery gift,” then let the whole room vote together.